# Madoline - Tome 2

**Brand:** EDITIONS FRANCE
**Category:** Livres & culture
**Code (GTIN/SKU):** 9782917456163
**Canonical URL:** https://openreviews.io/en/reviews/editionsfrance/madoline-tome-2-9782917456163

## Rating: 4.2/5 ★★★★☆ — 4 reviews analyzed
_Confidence: high_

## At a glance

Madoline - Tome 2 (EDITIONS FRANCE) reviews: 4.2/5 based on 4 analyzed reviews, updated November 21, 2026.

Praised: quality illustrations. Criticized: dated graphic style.

4 reviews analyzed, all published on other sites.
Other sites: 1 source, 4 reviews, average rating 4.2/5.
How we count reviews: https://openreviews.io/en/methodology

## AI summary

This second volume of the Madoline comic strip is primarily aimed at fans of collectible comics and retro works. The main appeal of this book lies in its illustrations, which bear the characteristic visual signature of the artist. However, the artist's highly specific and dated graphic style may not appeal to readers looking for contemporary productions or a more modern tone.

## Strengths

- **Quality illustrations** — The pages are created by the famous French cartoonist Georges Pichard, guaranteeing a unique aesthetic sought after by collectors.

## Weaknesses

- **Dated graphic style** — The very typical pencil stroke of Pichard's era may not appeal to all modern audiences.

## Frequently asked questions

- What is the graphic style of this album?
- Is the storyline as good as Pichard's drawings?
- Do you need to have read volume 1 to understand the story?
- Which audience is this comic book intended for?

---
_Source: OpenReviews — https://openreviews.io/en/reviews/editionsfrance/madoline-tome-2-9782917456163_
